STATIX SANS · Eurocode · BS 8110 Find a calculator…48 Start free trial
Learn · worked example

Strut-and-tie model of a deep wall to EN 1992-1-1

A deep wall carries its load by arching, not by bending. Here a strut-and-tie model of a 6 m wall with two 500 kN loads is solved by hand: the member forces by joint equilibrium, then the strut, tie and node checks of EN 1992-1-1 6.5. The hand calculation is checked against the STATIX strut-and-tie calculator.

1. The problem

InputValue
Memberdeep wall on two supports, 6 m between support centres, 3 m high
Thickness b0.2 m
Loads2 × 500 kN at 1.5 m and 4.5 m from the left support (design values)
Modelnodes at the tie level y = 0.15 m and the top chord y = 2.8 m; struts 1, 3: w = 0.35 m, strut 2: w = 0.30 m; tie 4: A_s = 1000 mm²
Platesbearing and load plates a = 0.3 m
Concretef_ck = 30 MPa, α_cc = 0.85
Steelf_yk = 450 MPa

2. The method EN 1992-1-1 6.5

A deep wall does not bend like a beam: plane sections do not stay plane. A strut-and-tie model replaces the concrete with a truss: concrete struts carry the compression, steel ties carry the tension, and they meet at nodes. The forces come from equilibrium alone, so the truss must be statically determinate. Then each strut, tie and node is checked against the limits of EN 1992-1-1 6.5. SANS 10100-1 has no strut-and-tie method, so this is the Eurocode route. The model here is the calculator's first starter model, "Deep wall, two loads, no opening": a 0.2 m thick wall on two supports 6 m apart with two loads of 500 kN.

1234500 kN500 kNR = 500 kNR = 500 kN1: C 574.5 kN3: C 574.5 kN2: C 283.0 kN4: T 283.0 kN5: 0 kN

3. Support reactions statics

Take moments about node 1 for the reaction at node 2, then sum the vertical forces. Node 1 is pinned and node 2 is on rollers, so no horizontal reaction is needed for vertical loads.

R_2 = (500 × 1.5 + 500 × 4.5) / 6.0 = 500.0 kN R_1 = 500 + 500 − 500.0 = 500.0 kN, R_1,x = 0

4. Joint equilibrium at node 4 method of joints

Start where only two members meet: node 4 under the right-hand load. Member 3 runs down to support node 2 over 1.50 m across and 2.65 m down, so it is 3.0451 m long. Its vertical part must carry the load; its horizontal part is balanced by member 2. C means compression.

L_3 = √(1.50² + 2.65²) = 3.0451 m vertical: C_3 × 2.65 / 3.0451 = 500 → C_3 = 500 × 3.0451 / 2.65 = 574.54 kN horizontal: C_2 = C_3 × 1.50 / 3.0451 = 283.02 kN

5. Joint equilibrium at node 3 method of joints

Node 3 has the other load, member 2 (now known), member 1 to node 1 and the diagonal member 5 to node 2. Two equations, two unknowns. With equal loads the diagonal carries nothing; it is there so the truss stays stable when the loads differ.

horizontal: C_1 × 1.50 / 3.0451 − 283.02 + F_5 × 4.50 / 5.2223 = 0 vertical: C_1 × 2.65 / 3.0451 − 500 − F_5 × 2.65 / 5.2223 = 0 → C_1 = 574.54 kN (compression), F_5 = 0.00 kN

6. Joint equilibrium at node 1: the tie method of joints

At support node 1 the strut 1 pushes down and inwards. The reaction takes the vertical part; the bottom tie, member 4, takes the horizontal part. The vertical part equal to R1 is the check that the sums close.

T_4 = C_1 × 1.50 / 3.0451 = 574.54 × 1.50 / 3.0451 = 283.02 kN (tension) vertical: C_1 × 2.65 / 3.0451 = 500.00 kN = R_1 = 500.00 kN OK

7. Design strengths EN 1992-1-1 6.5.2, 6.5.4, eq. 6.56, 6.57N, 6.60, 6.61

The concrete strength is reduced by ν' because struts and nodes are cracked and crossed by tension. Struts in a cracked zone get 0.6 ν' fcd (6.56); the calculator takes this for every strut unless a strut is marked uncracked (then fcd, 6.55), which is on the safe side. Nodes with no tie (CCC) get 1.0 ν' fcd (6.60), nodes with one tie (CCT) 0.85 ν' fcd (6.61). αcc = 0.85 is the calculator's default (the EN recommended value; the SANS 51992 annex uses 1.0).

f_cd = 0.85 × 30 / 1.5 = 17.000 MPa, ν' = 1 − 30 / 250 = 0.88 strut: 0.6 × 0.88 × 17.000 = 8.976 MPa CCC node: 1.0 × 0.88 × 17.000 = 14.960 MPa CCT node: 0.85 × 0.88 × 17.000 = 12.716 MPa f_yd = 450 / 1.15 = 391.30 MPa

8. The struts EN 1992-1-1 6.5.2, eq. 6.56

The stress in a strut is its force over its section: the wall thickness b times the strut width w drawn in the model. The inclined struts 1 and 3 are the same, so one check covers both.

struts 1 and 3: σ = C / (b w) = 574.54 / (0.2 × 0.35) / 1000 = 8.208 MPa ≤ 8.976 MPa OK, 92 % strut 2: σ = 283.02 / (0.2 × 0.30) / 1000 = 4.717 MPa ≤ 8.976 MPa OK, 53 %

9. The tie EN 1992-1-1 6.5.3

The tie steel must carry the tie force at the design yield strength.

A_s,req = T / f_yd = 283.02 × 1000 / 391.30 = 723.3 mm² ≤ 1000 mm² provided OK, 73 %

10. The nodes EN 1992-1-1 6.5.4, eq. 6.60, 6.61

Nodes 1 and 2 at the supports have one tie (CCT); nodes 3 and 4 under the loads have none (CCC). Each strut face and each bearing plate (0.3 m long) is checked against the node limit. The strut face stress is the strut stress from step 8. Nodes 2 and 4 are the mirror images of nodes 1 and 3.

node 1, strut face: 8.208 MPa ≤ 12.716 MPa (CCT) OK, 65 % node 1, bearing plate: R / (b a) = 500.0 / (0.2 × 0.3) / 1000 = 8.333 MPa ≤ 12.716 MPa OK, 66 % node 3, strut face: 8.208 MPa ≤ 14.960 MPa (CCC) OK, 55 % node 3, load plate: P / (b a) = 500 / (0.2 × 0.3) / 1000 = 8.333 MPa ≤ 14.960 MPa OK, 56 %

11. What the model leaves to you EN 1992-1-1 6.5.4(7), 8.4, 9.7

The calculator does not check the node geometry (the strut widths must fit the drawn nodes) or the tie anchorage past the support node: the tie must be anchored beyond the node. Both are the drawer's check on the drawing. Add the minimum web mesh of a deep beam on each face too (EN 1992-1-1 9.7).

12. The calculator's answer

The calculator, with the same model, gives the same forces: struts 1 and 3 C = 574.5 kN, strut 2 C = 283.0 kN, tie 4 T = 283.0 kN, member 5 zero (engine 1.4.3). The highest utilisation is the inclined strut, σ = 8.208 MPa against 8.976 MPa, 92 %, and the verdict is PASS. The hand calculation gives the same numbers. Try the second starter model, with an opening in the shear span, or change a load in the tables and watch the forces follow.

Run this example yourselfOpen the STATIX strut-and-tie calculator. This model is the calculator's default (the first starter model, with its default inputs), so it opens on this example. Change any value and the result updates, with every check and a calc sheet.
Open the strut-and-tie calculator

A worked example for learning, not a design. Check every value against the current code and your own project, and have the design checked and signed by a registered professional engineer.

Early access

Be first to use STATIX 3D.

STATIX 3D is still being built. Join the early-access list and we will tell you when it is ready for testing. One confirmation now, one message then.

Get early access