RC beam with a web opening
A duct through a beam web cuts the beam into two chords. Here the Vierendeel chord method is worked by hand: first the force split of a published test beam, then a SANS 10100-1 beam with a 400 x 180 mm opening. The hand calculation is checked against the STATIX RC beam web opening calculator.
1. The method
A web opening cuts the beam into a top chord and a bottom chord. Over the opening the beam works as a Vierendeel frame. The moment M becomes a pair of axial forces in the chords. The shear V is shared by the chords and bends each one. Each chord is then checked as a short member under N, M and V.
This is the Vierendeel chord method (Mansur & Tan; PCI Journal 1977). The design codes give no clause for web openings. The chords are checked to the section rules of the code you choose. This example has two parts:
- Part A: the force split of a published beam, checked against the paper.
- Part B: a SANS 10100-1 beam, the calculator's starting values, checked by hand.
2. Part A: the published check PCI Journal, Nov-Dec 1977, App. B
Source: Barney, Corley, Hanson, Parmelee, "Behavior and Design of Prestressed Concrete Beams with Large Web Openings", PCI Journal, Nov-Dec 1977, Appendix B. The paper is free on pci.org.
Limit of this part. The paper's beam is a prestressed double tee with a 50 mm topping (ACI 318-71). The calculator designs reinforced concrete only: no prestress, a rectangular section. So the calculator cannot run this beam. Part A checks the force split only (statics). There is no calculator run, no figure and no code check.
Units: 1 in = 25,4 mm; 1 kip = 4,448 kN; 1 in-kip = 0,1130 kNm.
| Hole A (centre 8,5 ft from the support) | Paper | SI | Engine (SI) |
|---|---|---|---|
| M_u | 1066 in-kip | 120,4 kNm | 120,4 kNm |
| V_u (V_d dead 2,9 kip) | 7,2 kip | 32,0 kN | 32,0 kN |
| d_s (lever arm of the struts) | 17,57 in | 446 mm | 446 mm |
| V_c = V I_c / (I_c + I_t,cr) = 7,2 x 214 / (214 + 72) | 5,4 kip | 24,0 kN | 24,0 kN |
| V_t = V_d I_t / (I_c' + I_t) + (V - V_d) I_t / (I_c + I_t) | 6,0 kip | 26,7 kN | 26,6 kN |
| M_c = V_c x 19 in (hinge at mid-length, strut 38 in) | 102,6 in-kip | 11,6 kNm | 11,6 kNm |
| M_t = V_t x 19 in | 114,0 in-kip | 12,9 kNm | 12,9 kNm |
Hole B: T = 31,9 kip > 6 A_g √f_c' = 24,7 kip. A crack goes through the full depth of the tension strut. The compression strut carries all of V: V_c = 2,3 kip (10,2 kN), V_t = 0, M_t = 0. The engine gives the same.
A note on N. The paper's C = 60 kip and T = 10,8 kip include the prestress P. The calculator has P = 0, so N = M / d_s = 270 kN at Hole A. The difference comes from the prestress. It is not an engine error.
3. Part B: the problem SANS 10100-1
These are the calculator's starting values, with the corner bar statement ticked.
| Input | Value |
|---|---|
| Beam | b 300 mm, h 600 mm |
| Materials | f_cu 30 MPa, f_y = f_yv 450 MPa |
| Cover and links | cover 30 mm, Y10 links |
| Opening | 400 x 180 mm; top chord h_t 220 mm, bottom chord h_b 200 mm; 900 mm clear from the support |
| Actions at the centre of the opening | M 100 kNm (sagging), V 70 kN |
| Bars | 3Y16 top + 2Y16 above the opening; 3Y20 bottom + 2Y16 below the opening |
| Links | chord links Y10 at 100 mm; full-depth links within e_s = 50 mm of each edge |
4. Lever arm and chord force statics
The chord forces act at the centre of each chord. The top chord is in compression and the bottom chord in tension.
5. Which chord carries the shear method (Mansur)
Compare the cracking force of the bottom chord with its tension.
The bottom chord is cracked through. So the top chord carries all of V: V_c = 70 kN, V_t = 0.
6. Chord moment method
The chord bends in double curvature over its effective length, with the hinge at mid-length.
7. Top chord: N + M SANS 10100-1 section rules, strain compatibility
The shift rule adds V times the chord's effective depth, d_c = 220 - 30 - 10 - 8 = 172 mm.
The engine checks N-M at the gross N (256,4 kN) and at the z_ub N (192,5 kN), and uses the worse. M_Rd = 35,85 kNm at N 192,5 kN.
8. Top chord: shear SANS 10100-1 4.3.4
The axial force adds to the concrete shear strength.
So minimum links are sufficient.
9. Top chord: link spacing SANS 10100-1 4.11.5
10. Bottom chord SANS 10100-1 section rules
The bottom chord takes N = 256,4 kN in tension. For the shift only, the uncracked stiffness share gives it a shear.
11. Links beside the opening method (PCI 1977 App. B step 6)
Provide this as full-depth links on each side, within 50 mm of the opening edge.
12. Corner bars practice rule, not a code value
This is a practice rule. You confirm the corner bars in the calculator.
13. The calculator's answer
The calculator, with the same inputs (engine 1.0.5), reads NOT CHECKED until you confirm the corner bars (a practice rule, never pre-ticked); then PASS, governing utilisation 0,824 (top chord N-M). The bottom chord N-M is 0,59. It asks for full-depth links of 179 mm² each side and corner bars of 126 mm² per corner. The hand calculation gives the same numbers.
Open the RC beam web opening calculator
A worked example for learning, not a design. Check every value against the current code and your own project, and have the design checked and signed by a registered professional engineer.
Be first to use STATIX 3D.
STATIX 3D is still being built. Join the early-access list and we will tell you when it is ready for testing. One confirmation now, one message then.