Laterally loaded pile to EN 1997-1
A free-head pile, 0.6 m wide and 10 m long in soft to firm clay, with a sideways load at the top. Here Broms' method for the ultimate lateral load is worked by hand, with the EN 1997-1 design value and the head deflection under the working load. The hand calculation is checked against the STATIX laterally loaded pile calculator.
1. The problem
| Input | Value |
|---|---|
| Soil | clay, undrained: c_u = 50 kPa (uniform) |
| Pile | width D = 0.6 m, embedded length L = 10 m, free head |
| Pile strength | yield moment M_y = 300 kNm, stiffness EI = 200 000 kNm² |
| Load | at e = 0.5 m above ground |
| Design load (ULS) | H_Ed = 150 kN |
| Working load | H_k = 100 kN, FS = 2.5 (practice) |
| Subgrade | k_h = 20 000 kN/m³ (constant), deflection limit 25 mm (practice) |
2. The method Broms 1964a
Broms gives the ultimate lateral load Hu of a single pile from simple soil pressure blocks. In clay the top 1.5 D gives no resistance (the soil there is pushed up and out); below it the soil resists with 9 cu D per metre of pile. The pile fails either as a short pile (it rotates as a rigid body, the soil fails along its whole length) or as a long pile (it forms a plastic hinge at the point of maximum moment). Hu is the lower of the two. This pile has a free head (no cap restraint).
3. Short pile: rigid rotation Broms 1964a
The soil reaction 9 cu D acts over a length f from 1.5 D down, where the shear in the pile is zero and the moment is largest. Below that, over the remaining length g, Broms takes the moment the soil can hold as 2.25 cu D g². Moments at the point of zero shear:
4. Long pile: yield at depth Broms 1964a
A 10 m pile in this clay is too long to rotate as a block: it bends first. The largest moment is at the point of zero shear, at depth 1.5 D + f. The pile fails when that moment reaches its yield moment My = 300 kNm:
5. Ultimate lateral resistance Broms 1964a
The pile takes the lower load of the two modes. Here the long-pile mode governs by a wide margin: the pile section, not the soil, sets the limit.
6. Design resistance to EN 1997-1 EN 1997-1 7.7; Annex A Table A.4
For the ULS check the calculator uses Design Approach 1, Combination 2: the undrained strength is divided by the M2 factor γcu = 1.4, and the same two modes are worked again. The long-pile mode still governs.
7. Working load against H_u / FS practice value
A second, older check: the working (characteristic) load against the ultimate load divided by a factor of safety. FS = 2.5 is a common practice value for Broms ultimate loads, not a code number. Here the working load is too high for it:
8. Head deflection Hetenyi (beam on elastic foundation); Broms 1964a
Broms gives the ultimate load only. For the deflection under the working load, the soil is taken as springs with a constant modulus kh (clay). β L tells if the pile acts long (β L ≥ 2.5) or short (β L ≤ 1.5). The load Hk acts at e above ground, so at ground level there is also a moment M = Hk e. The limit of 25 mm is a common practice value, not a code number.
9. The calculator's answer
The calculator, with the same inputs, gives Hu = 174.2 kN, Hu,d = 164.3 kN and y₀ = 6.9 mm (engine 1.1.2), the same as the hand calculation. Its verdict is FAIL: the ULS check and the deflection pass, but the working-load check with the practice FS = 2.5 does not. Lower Hk to 69 kN, or give a stronger pile (a larger My), and see it pass.
Open the laterally loaded pile calculator
A worked example for learning, not a design. Check every value against the current code and your own project, and have the design checked and signed by a registered professional engineer.
Be first to use STATIX 3D.
STATIX 3D is still being built. Join the early-access list and we will tell you when it is ready for testing. One confirmation now, one message then.