STATIX SANS · Eurocode · BS 8110 Find a calculator…48 Start free trial
Learn · worked example

Apex haunch connection to EN 1993-1-8

At the ridge of a portal frame two haunched rafters are joined by bolting their end plates together. Here the component method of EN 1993-1-8 is worked by hand for a sagging moment, from the actions on the plate to the moment resistance. The hand calculation is checked against the STATIX apex haunch connection calculator.

1. The problem

InputValue
Rafters457 × 191 × 67 UB both sides, S355, roof pitch 10° (apex angle 160°)
Haunchcut from the rafter (t_fh = t_f = 12.7 mm), 300 mm deep below the rafter, 500 mm long
End platestwo, extended, 180 mm wide, 20 mm thick, S355 (f_y = 345 MPa at 20 mm); depth set by the engine
BoltsM20 class 10.9, gauge 100 mm, 4 rows inside the rafter + haunch (2 at each flange, 80 mm pitch) + 1 above the rafter
Weldsfillets, 8 mm legs to the flanges and the web; haunch welds 6 mm
Design actionsM = 180 kNm (gravity: sagging, tension at the haunch bottom), V = 20 kN, N = 0

2. The method EN 1993-1-8 6.2.7.2(10), 6.2.6.7(2)

At the ridge two rafters meet, each with a welded end plate, and the plates are bolted together. EN 1993-1-8 6.2.7.2(10) treats this as a bolted splice: the component method of 6.2 is used with the items relating to the column left out, and the mating plate is the same (β = 0, so no web panel). Under gravity the apex sags: the bottom of the haunch is in tension and the rafter top flange is in compression. The calculator runs the STATIX app's end plate engine; for this sense of moment it turns the joint over, so in the steps below y is measured from the plate edge above the rafter. The page's "Cut from" is Rafter cutting by default, so the haunch is a cutting of the same 457 × 191 × 67 UB and its flange is the rafter flange, tfh = tf = 12.7 mm (the page fixes it today). γM0 = 1.0, γM2 = 1.25.

1234F_c = 297 kNforces on the right-hand plateshear rowrafter 457 × 191 × 67 at 10°haunch toehaunch 300 deep, 500 longtwo end plates 180 × 865 × 20

3. Actions on the plate SCI P398 Step 4

The plate is vertical but the rafters slope at 10°, so the shear along the rafter splits into a shear in the plate and a small axial force across it. The axial force acts on the rafter axis; the moment is taken about the centre of compression (the middle of the rafter top flange), so the axial force changes it by N hN.

V_plate = 20 × cos 10° = 19.70 kN, N_plate = 20 × sin 10° = 3.473 kN (compression) h_N = (d/2 − t_f/2) / cos 10° = (226.5 − 6.35) / 0.98481 = 223.55 mm M about the centre of compression = 180 − 3.473 × 0.22355 = 179.22 kNm

4. The joint geometry engine layout

The engine lays out the ridge plate itself: two rows from 45 mm below the rafter top fibre, two from 45 mm above the inner face of the haunch flange, 80 mm apart, and with the extended plate one more row 40 mm above the rafter top. That top row sits on the compression side of a sagging joint, so it is a shear row only. The end distance is 1.5 d0 = 33 mm rounded up to 35 mm (a practice value of the engine). On the plumb cut the 10° rafter is 453 / cos 10° deep and its 12.7 mm flange is 12.7 / cos 10° deep. Every step is worked by hand, except the chart reading α of Figure 6.11 for row 1 and the other checks near the end, which are said to come from the calculator.

rafter on the plumb cut: 453 / cos 10° = 459.99 mm flush plate: max(459.99 + 300 + 40, 459.99 + 300 + 60) = 819.99 mm, centred on the haunched depth: it reaches 30.00 mm above the rafter top extended: the top row needs 40 + 35 = 75 mm above the rafter top → + 45.00 mm, h_p = 864.99 mm centre of compression: y_c = 75 + (12.7 / cos 10°) / 2 = 75 + 12.896 / 2 = 81.448 mm row 1: y = 789.99 mm, h_1 = 789.99 − 81.448 = 708.5 mm row 2: y = 709.99 mm, h_2 = 709.99 − 81.448 = 628.5 mm row 3: y = 200.00 mm, h_3 = 200.00 − 81.448 = 118.6 mm row 4: y = 120.00 mm, h_4 = 120.00 − 81.448 = 38.6 mm shear row: y = 35 mm (above the rafter top, beyond y_c)

5. Bolt resistances EN 1993-1-8 3.6.1, Table 3.4

M20 class 10.9: As = 245 mm², fub = 1000 MPa; αv = 0.5 for class 10.9.

F_t,Rd = 0.9 × 1000 × 245 / 1.25 / 1000 = 176.4 kN, two bolts per row: 352.8 kN F_v,Rd = 0.5 × 1000 × 245 / 1.25 / 1000 = 98.0 kN

6. Rows 2 to 4: the end plate EN 1993-1-8 6.2.6.5, 6.2.4 Table 6.2, Table 6.6

Every tension row is inside the rafter + haunch depth, so each end plate T-stub spans from the bolt to the web weld toe. Rows 2, 3 and 4 take the inner-row lengths of Table 6.6 (row 1, next to the haunch flange, follows in the next step). There is no column: the mating plate is the same plate, so one end plate T-stub per row is checked (6.2.7.2(10)). The rafter web in tension (6.2.6.8) is stronger.

m = 100/2 − 8.5/2 − 0.8 × 8 = 39.35 mm, e = (180 − 100)/2 = 40 mm, n = min(e, 1.25 m) = 40 mm ℓ_eff,1 = min(2πm, 4m + 1.25e) = min(247.2, 207.4) = 207.4 mm, ℓ_eff,2 = 207.4 mm, M_pl = 0.25 × 207.4 × 20² × 345 / 10⁶ = 7.155 kNm mode 1: 4 × 7.155 / 0.03935 = 727.3 kN; mode 2: (2 × 7.155 + 0.040 × 352.8) / (0.03935 + 0.040) = 358.2 kN; mode 3: 352.8 kN rafter web in tension: 207.4 × 8.5 × 355 / 1000 = 625.8 kN F_r,Rd = 352.8 kN for each of rows 2 to 4 (the bolts govern)

7. Row 1: the end plate next to the haunch flange EN 1993-1-8 6.2.6.5, Table 6.6, Figure 6.11

Under the sagging moment the haunch flange is the tension flange, and row 1 is the first bolt row next to it: the flange stiffens its T-stub. Table 6.6 gives this row ℓeff,cp = 2πm and ℓeff,nc = αm. α depends on λ1 = m / (m + e) and λ2 = m2 / (m + e), where m2 is the bolt to the toe of the flange weld: row 1 is 45 mm from the inner face of the haunch flange (the layout of step 4), less 0.8 × the 8 mm leg. α is read from Fig. 6.11 by the calculator: α = 5.8207 at λ1 = 0.4959, λ2 = 0.4865 (a chart reading, not worked here; the calculator takes the lowest α along λ1 up to this value, so α never rises as λ1 grows). Everything after α is worked by hand.

m = 39.35 mm, e = 40 mm, n = 40 mm, m2 = 45 − 0.8 × 8 = 38.6 mm λ1 = 39.35 / (39.35 + 40) = 0.4959, λ2 = 38.6 / 79.35 = 0.4865 α = 5.8207 (read from Fig. 6.11 by the calculator) ℓ_eff,cp = 2π × 39.35 = 247.24 mm, ℓ_eff,nc = α m = 5.8207 × 39.35 = 229.04 mm ℓ_eff,1 = min(ℓ_eff,cp, ℓ_eff,nc) = 229.04 mm, ℓ_eff,2 = ℓ_eff,nc = 229.04 mm, M_pl = 0.25 × 229.04 × 20² × 345 / 10⁶ = 7.902 kNm mode 1: 4 × 7.902 / 0.03935 = 803.3 kN; mode 2: (2 × 7.902 + 0.040 × 352.8) / (0.03935 + 0.040) = 377.0 kN; mode 3: 352.8 kN rafter web in tension: 229.04 × 8.5 × 355 / 1000 = 691.1 kN F_1,Rd = 352.8 kN (the bolts govern, as with the inner-row length)

8. Row groups EN 1993-1-8 6.2.6.5, Table 6.6

Rows 1 and 2 at the haunch flange are 80 mm apart, so their yield lines overlap and they must also be checked as a pair; every other run of adjacent rows is checked too. Σℓeff adds a length per row (Table 6.6, rows as part of a group): row 1 heading a group is the first row below the flange, ℓeff,nc = 0.5p + αm − (2m + 0.625e) and ℓeff,cp = πm + p, with the same α as in the last step; any other end row of the group 2m + 0.625e + 0.5p and πm + p; an inner row 0.5(pabove + pbelow) and pabove + pbelow. Modes 1 and 2 use ℓeff,1 = min(Σℓeff,nc, Σℓeff,cp) and ℓeff,2 = Σℓeff,nc, mode 3 all the bolts of the group, and the rafter web in tension over ℓeff,1 caps the group.

group 1–2: Σℓ_eff,nc = [0.5 × 80 + 5.8207 × 39.35 − (2 × 39.35 + 0.625 × 40)] + (2 × 39.35 + 0.625 × 40 + 0.5 × 80) = 165.34 + 143.70 = 309.04 mm Σℓ_eff,cp = 2 × (π × 39.35 + 80) = 407.24 mm, ℓ_eff,1 = ℓ_eff,2 = 309.04 mm M_pl = 0.25 × 309.04 × 20² × 345 / 10⁶ = 10.662 kNm mode 1: 4 × 10.662 / 0.03935 = 1083.8 kN; mode 2: (2 × 10.662 + 0.040 × 705.6) / (0.03935 + 0.040) = 624.4 kN; mode 3: 4 × 176.4 = 705.6 kN rafter web: 309.04 × 8.5 × 355 / 1000 = 932.5 kN → F_1-2,Rd = 624.4 kN (mode 2) all groups (ℓ_eff,1 / ℓ_eff,2 in mm → F_Rd in kN, governing): end plate group 1–2: 309.0 / 309.0 → 624.4 (mode 2) end plate group 1–3: 819.0 / 819.0 → 1058.4 (mode 3) end plate group 1–4: 899.0 / 899.0 → 1411.2 (mode 3) end plate group 2–3: 717.4 / 717.4 → 705.6 (mode 3) end plate group 2–4: 797.4 / 797.4 → 1058.4 (mode 3) end plate group 3–4: 287.4 / 287.4 → 605.6 (mode 2)

9. The compression zone EN 1993-1-8 6.2.6.7

The compression goes through the rafter top flange. With the haunch the section is deeper than 600 mm, so 6.2.6.7(1) limits the web to 20 % of the resistance: the flange force alone, divided by 0.8 (the engine's rafter table has b = 190 mm). The plates bear on each other, so there is no column web to check.

F_c,fb,Rd = 12.7 × 190 × 355 × 1.25 / 1000 = 1070.8 kN

10. Moment resistance EN 1993-1-8 6.2.7.2; SCI P398 Step 4 (force line)

As for the eaves haunch, the engine shares the moment among the tension rows in proportion to their distance from the centre of compression: Fr = M hr / Σh², and the compression is ΣFr + N. Mj,Rd is the moment at which the first row, row group or the compression zone reaches its resistance. The two rows near the rafter top have short lever arms and carry little.

Σh = 1.49418 m, Σh² = 0.91263 m², Σh / Σh² = 1.63722 per m rafter flange in compression, (F_c − N): M = (1070.8 − 3.47) / 1.63722 = 651.9 kNm row 1 alone: M = 352.8 / 0.77637 = 454.4 kNm end plate group 1–2: M = 624.4 / 1.46508 = 426.2 kNm the other end plate groups (step 8): the lowest moment is from end plate group 1–3, 1058.4 kN → M = 663.6 kNm M_j,Rd = 426.2 kNm (the group of rows 1 and 2 governs); M_Ed = 180 kNm → 43 %

11. Forces at the design moment EN 1993-1-8 6.2.7.2

At the design moment (179.22 kNm about the centre of compression) the rows carry their share and the flange takes the sum plus the axial force.

F_1 = 179.22 × 0.70854 / 0.91263 = 139.14 kN F_2 = 179.22 × 0.62854 / 0.91263 = 123.43 kN F_3 = 179.22 × 0.11855 / 0.91263 = 23.28 kN F_4 = 179.22 × 0.03855 / 0.91263 = 7.57 kN F_c,Ed = 293.43 + 3.473 = 296.90 kN ≤ 1070.8 kN (28 %) row 1: 139.14 ≤ 352.8 kN (40 %); group 1–2: 262.58 ≤ 624.4 kN (43 %)

12. The prying allowance at the haunch row STATIX practice allowance (not an EN 1993-1-8 rule)

This check is the engine's own, not a code rule: a reference finite element program put about twice the EN 1993-1-8 row force on the bolt row next to the haunch flange of a bolted apex, so until the cause is known the engine multiplies the force in that row by 2.1 and checks it against the two bolts. It is a practice value, and here it governs the joint.

2.1 × F_1 = 2.1 × 139.14 = 292.2 kN ≤ 2 F_t,Rd = 352.8 kN OK, 82.8 %

13. Flange welds and shear EN 1993-1-8 4.5.3, Table 3.4; SCI P398 shear-row rule

Each flange has two 8 mm fillets across its 190 mm width (a = 5.6 mm, L = 380 mm); the directional method gives the same resistance as at the eaves. The shear row takes the full Fv,Rd per bolt (bearing on the plate, 207.9 kN as at the eaves, is larger); the eight bolts of the tension rows add 0.28 Fv,Rd each.

F_w,Rd = 490 × 5.6 × 380 / (√2 × 0.9 × 1.25) / 1000 = 655.4 kN ≥ F_c,Ed = 296.9 kN OK, 46 % V_j,Rd = 2 × 98.0 + 8 × 0.28 × 98.0 = 415.52 kN ≥ V_plate = 19.70 kN OK, 5 %

14. The other checks EN 1993-1-8 6.2.3(2), 6.2.6.7(2); EN 1993-1-5 6.2, 7.2; Table 3.3

These are quoted from the calculator, not worked here: the axial force is below 5 % of Npl,Rd of the rafter (6.2.3(2)); the haunch rules of 6.2.6.7(2) hold (same grade, a cutting of the rafter, the flange at atan(300/500) = 31.0° ≤ 45°); the rafter web at the haunch toe and the toe section (with M = 180 − 20 × 0.5 = 170 kNm there) pass; the welds, the bolt spacing of Table 3.3 and block tearing pass.

rafter web at the toe: 199 ≤ 491 kN (41 %); toe yield check: 211 ≤ 355 MPa (60 %)

15. The calculator's answer

The calculator, with the same inputs, gives Mj,Rd = 426.2 kNm (engine statix-endplate-engine stage 1 (app build 0.10.678, sha256 88db02ce1a40)) and PASS at 82.8 %, governed by the prying allowance at the haunch row. The hand calculation gives the same numbers. Without the haunch the same plates and bolts give 250.8 kNm. Under wind uplift (a negative M in the calculator) the rafter top is in tension and the extended row works.

hand: M_j,Rd = 426.20 kNm, F_1 = 139.14 kN, 2.1 F_1 = 292.2 kN (82.8 %), F_c,Ed = 296.90 kN calculator: M_j,Rd = 426.20 kNm, F_1 = 139.14 kN, 2.1 F_1 = 292.2 kN (82.8 %), F_c,Ed = 296.90 kN (PASS)
Run this example yourselfOpen the STATIX apex haunch connection calculator. These are the calculator's default inputs (Cut from: Rafter cutting, so the haunch flange is the rafter flange), so it opens on this example. Change any value and the result updates, with every check and a calc sheet.
Open the apex haunch connection calculator

A worked example for learning, not a design. Check every value against the current code and your own project, and have the design checked and signed by a registered professional engineer.

Early access

Be first to use STATIX 3D.

STATIX 3D is still being built. Join the early-access list and we will tell you when it is ready for testing. One confirmation now, one message then.

Get early access